The court docket listening to about whether or not Adan Syed, a Baltimore man whose authorized saga was the idea for hit podcast “Serial,” ought to have his 1999 homicide conviction overturned is on maintain whereas the court docket waits for the sufferer’s brother to hitch the proceedings.
Baltimore Circuit Choose Melissa Phinn is holding a listening to to find out if Syed’s conviction for the killing of Hae Min Lee, his ex-high college sweetheart, needs to be overturned and if he needs to be launched from custody. Prosecutors filed a movement final Wednesday questioning the integrity of Syed’s authentic trial and the proof that he has left him behind bars these previous 23 years.
In Maryland, victims of crime have a proper to be heard at proceedings concerning the accused, and Lee’s brother, Younger Lee, represents the household. His lawyer, Steve Kelly, stated Younger Lee didn’t be taught of the listening to till Friday and requested Phinn to postpone the listening to for seven days so Lee, who lives in California, may attend.
Phinn denied that movement, saying adequate discover was given to Younger Lee and recessed court docket for half-hour so he may be part of just about and say his half earlier than Phinn guidelines on Syed’s guilt. Courtroom is anticipated to renew round 3:15 pm
Syed, 41, has all the time maintained his innocence.
Hae Min Lee, 18, was strangled to demise and buried in a clandestine grave in Leakin Park. Authorities on the time stated they suspected that Syed, her ex-boyfriend of her, struggled together with her in a automobile earlier than killing her. The state’s principle? The favored honors scholar at Woodlawn Excessive College could not deal with it when Lee broke up with him. He was 17 on the time of his arrest, and has been behind bars for 23 years.
Syed is presently incarcerated on the Patuxent Establishment, a state jail in Jessup.
Within the state’s movement to overturn his conviction, prosecutors wrote not that they believed Syed was harmless, however that they now not had religion within the integrity of his conviction.
“It’s within the pursuits of justice and equity that these convictions be vacated and that the defendant, at a minimal, be afforded a brand new trial,” wrote Becky Feldman, chief of the State’s Lawyer’s Workplace’s Sentencing Evaluate Unit.
Syed’s first trial in 1999 ended with a mistrial. In 2000, a jury discovered him responsible of homicide. The decide handed down life plus 30 years in jail at sentencing.
Regardless of combating to uphold the conviction in years previous, prosecutors now say Syed will not be Lee’s killer. In response to their movement to vacate his conviction of him, the state has recognized since 1999 of two “various suspects” who could have killed Lee.
One of many suspects had threatened her, saying “he would make her disappear. He would kill her,” prosecutors wrote.
The state didn’t disclose the choice suspects to Syed’s protection earlier than trial, which means his attorneys could not use that info to argue his innocence to a jury.
Prosecutors described one of many suspects as a serial rapist, saying the suspect was convicted in a sequence of sexual assaults after Syed’s trial. Police found Lee’s automobile close to the residence of one of many suspects, the state’s movement stated.
Syed was convicted, partly, due to cellphone location knowledge that has since been discovered to be unreliable, in line with prosecutors. In addition they highlighted the inconsistent statements of his co-defendant, Jay Wilds, who testified in opposition to him.
“Given the gorgeous lack of dependable proof implicating Mr. Syed, coupled with rising proof pointing to different suspects, this unjust conviction can’t stand,” stated Erica Suter, Syed’s lawyer and director of the Innocence Undertaking clinic on the College of Baltimore College of Regulation .
Syed’s conviction turned a matter of worldwide intrigue after “Serial,” a podcast launched in 2014 that pioneered the true crime style, raised new questions on Lee’s demise. Since then, his authorized journey has been the topic of books, different podcasts and tv documentaries which spawned new authorized filings in his case.
The courts turned down all of his appeals, the final in 2019, when the Supreme Courtroom declined to listen to his case.
Issues have been quiet till this spring.
Behind the scenes, Suter had been working with prosecutors in hopes of lowering Syed’s jail time period in mild of a brand new state legislation enabling these convicted of crimes earlier than they flip 18 to ask the court docket to switch their punishment.
Breaking Information Alerts
because it occurs
Be told of breaking information because it occurs and notified about different don’t-miss content material with our free information alerts.
Whereas inspecting the case, prosecutors agreed to request new DNA testing for objects collected as proof of Lee’s killing.
Phinn ordered the assessments in March, however the outcomes have thus far been inconclusive, court docket paperwork present. Checks for a couple of of the objects are pending.
Lee’s household has maintained their perception Syed is responsible and have struggled with the publicity and help Syed receives.
“It stays arduous to see so many run to defend somebody who dedicated a horrible crime, who destroyed our household, who refuses to simply accept duty, when so few are keen to talk up for Hae,” the household stated in a 2016 assertion issued by way of the Maryland Lawyer Common’s Workplace.
“Not like those that study this case on the Web,” the household stated then, “we sat and watched on daily basis of each trials — so many witnesses, a lot proof.”
The Lee household has not spoken publicly in regards to the case since.
This story will likely be up to date.