Skip to content

Poisonous masculinity is a part of elite hockey. We’d like a tradition shift

This column is an opinion from Alexis Peters, a sociology teacher in Calgary. For extra details about CBC’s Opinion partplease see the FAQ.

I am extraordinarily involved concerning the allegations of group sexual assault by previous males’s World Junior groups, and the way they had been dealt with. However am I shocked? Sadly not.

For greater than twenty years, I have been learning the poisonous masculinity of hockey and its results on the well being and well-being of high-performance athletes.

My analysis was initially knowledgeable by being a registered nurse whose accomplice was knowledgeable hockey participant in a mid-level skilled league. Seeing the hockey life up shut, I turned involved concerning the total well being of many gamers.

So, when my accomplice moved on to a Danish hockey crew, I enrolled on the College of Western Ontario to check poisonous masculinity and its results on males’s total bodily, psychological, and social well being and well-being. I targeted my PhD on the well being of elite athletes, particularly elite junior-level hockey gamers.

What budding hockey stars consider

To check how the hockey tradition of poisonous masculinity affected the athletes, I distributed questionnaires to a number of Ontario Hockey League junior hockey groups, measuring their attitudes towards hypermasculinity. These elite gamers, between the ages of 18 and 22, scored notably increased than my management group on the “hypermasculinity scale” as measured by three ideas: hazard as thrilling, violence as manly, and extra calloused attitudes towards intercourse.

One other sudden discovering was that in addition they scored considerably decrease on emotional empathy. It is necessary to notice that I used to be evaluating these OHL junior hockey gamers to a bunch of younger males who had not performed hockey previous Grade 11.

I concluded then, and nonetheless consider, that hockey tradition wants radical modifications to allow elite athletes to become wholesome people. Merely altering the individuals within the positions of energy, codes of conduct, and zero-tolerance insurance policies are usually not sufficient.

Prevention of many types of violence — sexual assault, harassment, abuse, hazing, and initiation rites — requires a extra complete academic strategy to alter the poisonous attitudes that many athletes are studying.

For instance, I argue that a method for junior hockey to alter from that poisonous masculine tradition is to cease encouraging the idea that “actual males play by means of the ache.” This usually makes it troublesome for athletes to confess when they’re damage or struggling although bodily, psychological, or emotional ache, particularly to different males.

The code of silence is actual, and gamers are pressured to go alongside for concern of being ostracized by the gamers or kicked off the crew. The considered presumably dropping your dream and identification that you’ve labored so arduous for isn’t straightforward at any age.

For years, coaches and fogeys would accuse researcher Alexis Peters of disliking hockey for proposing academic workshops to enhance hockey tradition. (PhotoDuets/Shutterstock)

Gamers study this poisonous masculinity, and are rewarded for these behaviors at a really early age and from many individuals. Maybe that’s the reason my analysis met quite a lot of resistance from sport directors, coaches, mother and father, and followers. It’s simpler guilty “one unhealthy apple” than to just accept partial duty for encouraging a poisonous masculine tradition.

After I steered plenty of academic workshops and shifting hockey tradition from poisonous masculinity to a mannequin centered across the pursuit of excellence, I usually obtained accused of disliking hockey and sports activities. However belief me, nothing might be farther from the reality.

I preserve that there are a lot of constructive life expertise that may be discovered by means of collaborating in sport, akin to resilience, time administration and management expertise. I proceed to show my analysis in all my college programs, and scholar athletes themselves by no means put up resistance to the concepts others had been reluctant to just accept.

Many of those younger males don’t make it to any mid-professional league and are left with lifelong attitudes that may show to be damaging to their well being, akin to poor emotional literacy, a perception they need to endure in silence, and an enormous loss to their identification. My solely hope now could be that out of this horrible scenario individuals will lastly take heed to the tales of many athletes with an open thoughts and make hockey a protected place for each little one to pursue their desires and passions.

If all of us take some duty to assist make hockey all of the great issues it may be, I stay optimistic that altering the tradition can arrange everybody — women and men — for a more healthy life.


Do you will have a robust opinion that would add perception, illuminate a difficulty within the information, or change how individuals take into consideration a difficulty? We need to hear from you. Here is the way to pitch to us.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.